I thought a lot about this, and also the option of DAH, which is similar in that it almost guarantees you'll get the rides you want. In the end, we chose the club level FP program for a few reasons- first, we don't see the waiting time between FP as a problem- we haven't been to WDW in years so catching up on all the "lesser" attractions is very appealing. It's not all about the rides for us. Second, there are the other, numerous amenities of staying club level; and finally, we just don't want another person hanging with our family- the kids are (technically) grown up and we don't all live in the same place anymore, so we're looking forward to enjoying each other's company without a third party around.