Mom and I ate here in December and it was by far the best meal we've ever had on property. It's still pretty much a big secret at Disney it seems - rarely hear anyone talk about it on these boards and it was nowhere near full when we were there. Made for a nice, quiet, relaxing meal.
Our waitress was very attentive without hovering, and the food was just. . . my mouth is watering thinking about it. I had the filet and was very impressed that they managed to make it well done (I'm picky, pink turns my stomach, LOL) and it was still SO juicy, tender and flavorful. I'm trying to remember what mom had. . . veal maybe? I think we both savored every single bite.
We're debating going back in September. I made an ADR for California Grill because I knew it'd fill up and at least this way we have the ADR in case we decide to go there. . . if we change our mind, it'll be no problem to cancel CG and get a spot at Citrico's. As much as I wanna try CG, I'd really love to go for Citrico's again so it'll be a tough decision as our travel dates near.
As for what to wear, I had black slacks a blouse and heels and mom had slacks, a sweater and dress shoes. There was a range of outfits - from dressy casual to just dressy.