Citricos vs. Artist Point vs. Narcoossees

[cbeeindisney]

Hi!

DH and I have one more meal to decide on and I'm having trouble deciding between these signature restaurants for our last night's dinner. We haven't been to any of these and I'm looking for experiences and advice to help point me in the right direction.

Thank you!!

 

[OKW Lover]

We've been to all three of these and you won't go wrong with any of them. So, you probably just need to decide based on the likes/dislikes of your dining party. Suggest getting everybody together to look at their menus on line and then make a group decision.

 

[DisneyWishes14]

I've been to all three multiple times and Artist Point would be my choice. Both times we went to Narcoosee's were very expensive disappointments. Citrico's is hit or miss. Artist Point has been consistently stellar both for food and service, plus I love the quiet, serene atmosphere of the restaurant.

 

[disneygolfer1985]

The ambiance and food of Artist Point is phenomenal. I have had the best salmon ever there! Very moist and tasty. I have never been to Citrico's, but have liked Narcoossee's. We are going to Artist Point for Thanksgiving this year.

 

[steg]

Never tried any of them. But, FWIW I most want to try Artist Point, Narcoosees seems too bland/safe with regards to their menu in comparison to the others. I don't think I'll ever make it to Citricos as I know I'll feel sad walking by Victoria and Albert's because I won't be eating there, but instead Citricos. I'd have to have already eaten at V&A the night before in order to walk past there and not feel bad.

 

[CraigInPA]

I've eaten at all three, multiples times each. There is no bad choice here.

Personally, I like Artist Point more than the others. My wife would say Narcoossee's is her favorite. We both agree that Citrico's, despite the lack of a view and a rather bland room, has excellent and well prepared food.

 

[thumpergirl101]

I've never tried Artist Point, but I'm intimately familiar with Citricos and Narcoossee's.

In my opinion, Narc's has better food but Citricos has a better ambience. Narc's has a lovely location down by the water, and a slightly more relaxed vibe than Citricos, but I think the tables are too close together, so the dining room feels a bit crowded.

Citricos food is excellent, but didn't have the jaw-dropping factor that my meal at Narcoossee's did. That is, besides the Warm-Chocolate and banana torte from the dessert menu, which is basically my reason for existence.

 

[JennyDrake]

I'm a Hard Core Foodie and I vote Citricos. Everything I've had there is simply outstanding! You can't go wrong with Artist Point, but I was not Wowed there as I was at Citricos--still never had a bad meal there! Narcoosse is also quite good. If memory serves, the menu is heavy on seafood--so it may depend upon your party's tastes.

 

[Dean Marino]

Wellllll?

All three . Our ranking, which would VERY MINOR differences? Best to worst:

1) Citricos
2) Narcoossee's
3) Artist Point.

Now- every trip? We go to all three. There is not a looser in the bunch.

 

[Linleedo]

Hi!

DH and I have one more meal to decide on and I'm having trouble deciding between these signature restaurants for our last night's dinner. We haven't been to any of these and I'm looking for experiences and advice to help point me in the right direction.

Thank you!!

Narcoossee's hands down. Better food quality, service and ambiance. We experienced poor service at Citricos ( being ignored for larger groups/larger tips). The food at Artist Point was cold and the service was slow. We only return to Narcoossee's over and over again.

 

[kastoney]

For me it would be Artist Point or Narcoosee's. We've eaten at each of them a few time and the meals have never disappointed. Narcoossee's served some of the best scallops I ever had and Artist Point had the most amazing fried oyster appetizer. We've eaten at Citricos a few times too and it is by no means bad, I just feel like their food isn't on the same culinary level as the others.

Here are our last few reviews:
Artist Point - http://www.disboards.com/threads/99...ed-8-8-yachtsman.3510990/page-5#post-55834081

Citricos - http://www.disboards.com/threads/99...d-8-8-yachtsman.3510990/page-14#post-56155913

Naracossee's - http://www.disboards.com/threads/a-...-updated-4-11-x2.3458016/page-8#post-54877129

 

[Pepper pots]

Any of these three should be very good...We tried AP last trip in 2014 only because we were staying at WL..Wow!..It was awesome, so much so we have booked it for October this year as once again we are staying at WL..I have an ADR for Narcoossees also in October, and the reason I opted for that restaurant at GF over Citricos was I preferred the menu and the reviews on trip advisor ...