Normally, I tell people to avoid Narcoosees at all costs. It's not because it's bad, it's because it's SO GOOD! It's been getting a lot of excellent reviews and a lot of publicity lately. I don't want it to be difficult for me to get ressies!
But, since it's you, Jenny - I'll give you the real scoop. Narcoossees ROCKS!
I don't know if you keep Kosher. If not and you're on the Dining Plan, the surf & turf is WELL worth the 2 credits. And, the Mussels appetizer is phenominal! The scallops are wonderful, as well. (If you *do* keep Kosher, I guess that wasn't much help, was it?)
Also, the service there is the best we've experienced on property (outside of V&A). If you can, try and get ressies between 7:45-8:15 - Wishes is great to see from that vantage point.
And, here's another tip... if you enjoy Margaritas, Sergio (I *think* that's his name), makes the absolute BEST ones on property - hands down. If you go, tell him we said, "Hi!" and that we recommended him. (No, we don't know him personally, but we always make sure to go out of our way to acknowledge him when we dine there. Not only does he make an outstanding Margarita, but he's just very "professional", not like a typical bartender.)
So, don't tell anyone else - but you can't go wrong with Narcoosees. Keep it a hidden gem!