I'm sure you'll get the whole spectrum from it was bad, to it was better then we were expecting. The thing that almost everyone will probably agree on though, is that doing CRT you are usually doing it more for the atmosphere (it's the CASTLE!!) then the food
We ate there for my DD's 5th bday. The character interaction is great and we thought the food was very good. I must say I was surprised as I wasn't too sure if we'd like it. It was probably our 2nd favorite meal after Kona Cafe. The kids cleaned their plates - they had the chicken strips. Both DH and I had Major Domo's pie - very good. The appetizer was good as well - salad w/a delicious dressing, cheese & cold cuts (only one) & cold chicken w/some type of sauce. Very good. I ordered a bday cake for DD so we didn't try the desserts but our server did bring us each a bowl of ice cream to go w/our cake. It was fun - we'd do it again! We'll have to because DD2 won't remember eating there so we'll have to do it again.