It seems people either love it or hate it (experience wise) and I've read less than steller reviews of the food..ALL of the adults at my table thought the food was delicious, esp. the breakfast potatoes & the stuffed french toast!
I asked for more french toast & the server brought it no problem, and others at my table asked for more potatoes, again on problem, but we did have an EXCELLENT server too!!
The kids ate their food o.k. but were too excited to eat tthat much, (I had 4 younger girls with me; 3,5, 6 & 7) so they thought it was great..Most of the princesses were great and spent sufficient time at our table for my needs, however Cinderella did not, I felt she was rushed thru the place and my dd's were trying to talk to her and she just kind of smiled & shook her head and only said a few words..
All in all, would I go back? Maybe on the dining plan but I just read the prices INCREASED

dramatically from what I paid in October..and I don't think I would pay that now..
I would suggest trying it at least once just for the experience of eating in the castle, that in itself was worth the money at least 1x, IMO.
Good luck with your decision!
Chip