But my husband and son preferred the Halloween party - probably cuz of the "free" candy.
Thoughts on
MNSSHP (we went 10/27/05):
Weather was warm enough to swim that week
It was great to see all the costumes
Trick-or-treating was the BEST!
The parade was awesome
Thoughts on
MVMCP (we went Dec. 04)
It was COLD!!!!!!
The decorations are beautiful
Crowds were manageable for both, although a little heavier for MVMCP (we went on a Sun. night I think, vs Thu. night for MNSSHP). We didn't get to any of the shows for each party, which I regret.
Overall I'd say you have to go to both, although there seems to be more to see/do during Dec. I enjoyed both parties, so do one a year if you have to.
My only tip is to get to the park early on the day of your party - any time after 4 PM, so you can get the most out of your tkts. Oh, and buy the tkts ahead of time to save $$.
~Linda