We have an old Rosie O'Donnell X-Mas cd and it has a bunch of traditional and non-traditional songs I like on it.
Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree
Nuttin' For Christmas
Winter Wonderland (I absolutely love the version on this CD, Macy Gray has such a pretty voice)
Ay, Ay, Ay It's Christmas
Spread A Little Love On Christmas Day (Destiny's Child)
The Bells Of St.Paul (It's so pretty, makes me almost cry)
Silver Bells (#1 X-mas song)
I'm Gonna E-Mail Santa
Christmas Auld Lang Syne (Marc Anthony sings this.. didn't know he could sing)
Other songs:
Believe - Josh Groban
Deck The Halls
I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus
Joy to the World
O' Come All Ye Faithful (I love singing this in church, it's just such a beautiful song)
Silent Night
The Little Drummer Boy
Frosty the Snowman
Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas
Holly Jolly Christmas
Here Comes Santa Close
An Old Fashioned Christmas
Jingle Bell Rock
I'll Be Home For Christmas
O' Christmas Tree
White Christmas
The Night Before Christmas (Especially my parents version, I'll show it to you if I can find it.)