I would totally eat Christmas Eve dinner at Storyteller's Cafe. The atmosphere is just warm, cozy and homey with the softer glow lighting and the big fireplace. It just screams Christmas Eve to me!!
Last year for Christmas we ate at the Jazz Kitchen then for Christmas dinner Napa Rose. I have to be honest the dinner was excellent at NR but for $200.00 and no drinks other then one coke I would never do it again. I would try storytellers next time or Granille steak house ( I forget the new name) No matter what you do and where you eat it is great being in DL at Christmas time, I'll have merrories of that for life.