I've been debating the same thing for our trip next year. We need three nights after our DVC points run out. I love both hotels, but have finally decided on WL. I think because of all our trips during December, we have only stayed at WL in April/May for some reason. I wanted to stay at WL during Christmas. Plus, I love the pool and food better at WL. If they could move the animals outside my window, it would be a perfect stay.