Thanks for everyone’s thoughts and ideas.
Considering age
*Infants (less than one) generally don’t walk until close to their birthdays and even when they learn to sit-up it’s a while before they can sit well independently on a moving ride vehicle. They often spend ride time on someone’s lap or being worn in a carrier. Their enjoyment of rides improves as they get older. They tend to like colors and music and really just being with their families. Honestly at this age it’s often about just being able to do it all as a family and not having mom and dad split up and ride separately with older children.
*From 1-2 years of age a child changes a lot. A one year old is likely not frightened by the Tough to be a Bug Attraction, but at two that same child may be absolutely terrified. Sometime during this age most children will hit the 32” and possibly 36” milestones allowing them to ride the lowest height requirement rides at DCA.
*Between 3-5 years most children will hit the 40” milestone and many will hit the 42”. Especially tall children may even reach the 48” milestone. Thrill seekers may enjoy rollercoaster and other more thrilling rides, but lots of children at this age are timid about those kinds of rides.
In general children 5 and younger take more care than older children. They tend to accompany strollers, snacks, and tantrums. The park rules require children younger than 7 to be with an adult 14 or older at all times.
Considering attractions
DCA was not built with small children in mind. When the original park opened attractions younger guests could attend included the following still open attractions: Animation Academy, Golden Zephyr, It’s Tough to be a Bug!, King Triton’s Carousel, Redwood Creek Trail, Mickey’s Fun Wheel, and the Boudin Bakery. The Animation Academy, Redwood Creek Trail, and King Triton’s Carousel are all pretty great places for kids to spend some time. But It’s Tough to be a Bug! is often too scary for small children and the Boudin Bakery tour is not exactly entertaining, though they get a small snack. Golden Zephyr is a decent ride if you’re not afraid of heights and many children may enjoy it, but children may not lap sit on this ride, so it is a no go for infants. The non moving cars on the Fun Wheel would be okay for small children.
According to touringplans.com Bugsland opened in October of 2002, almost two years after the park opened. It added 5 attractions geared toward younger children, four rides and a splash pad. Flik’s Flyers and Heimlich have no height requirements and can be enjoyed by the smallest guests. Ladybug Boogie requires a child to sit on their own, no lap sitting, and it flings you around so they need to be a good sitter. Tuck and Roll’s has a 36” height requirement. This is the only area in DCA specifically designed for kids.
Playhouse Disney (Disney Junior) and Turtle Talk with Crush opened in 2003 and 2005 and are great shows for young children. In 2006 Monster’s Inc. replaced the long closed Superstar Limo ride. It uses the same ride system but is much more kid friendly than the original. It has no height requirements. Toy Story (2008) was a brand new ride that can be ridden by anyone, but it’s probably more fun for those two plus. The little Mermaid (2011) did replace an attraction’s location, but it is a brand new ride system and is definitely built for families to ride together. A handful of new meet and greets have popped up throughout DCA over the years too including Toy Story, Marvel, and Frozen.
Carsland opened in 2012 and it is definitely a kid friendly place. Radiator Springs Racers, the headline attraction has a 40” requirement, but it’s not scary so it should appeal to younger guests. The other two rides have small requirements of 32”. There’s also the meet and greets in the land and the DJ Dance ‘N Drive show.
My original thought was that they should definitely not remove Bugsland, kids need that space. And I still feel they do. However, I was surprised to realize just how much there is for little kids to do compared to when DCA opened 16 years ago. Our family really enjoys DCA and we have no trouble spending several days there over a long trip.
Considering location
The new Guardian’s ride is right next to Bugsland. And behind Bugsland is backstage area. It has been speculated that that could all be used for Marvel expanding the park that way and leaving the area from the Hyperion over alone. Of course that seems strange since there is so much blank space in the backlot. I would much prefer they used that area rather than tear down Bugsland, but I could see Bugsland being on the list of possible sites given it’s location near the existing Marvel attraction and the backstage area.