We ate at both Chef Mickey's & Cape May Cafe this past Sept. We LOVED Chef Mickey's: food & service was very good, great atmosphere, & excellent character interaction. This quickly became one of our most favorite places & have it scheduled for this Sept. Cape May was good, but it didn't overly impress us. IMO, the buffet at Cape May was somewhat small & limited compared to Chef Mickey's. The character interaction at Cape May was excellent & the service was also very good. We would eat at Cape May again, but it is not a "must do" for us and therefore, we did not schedule it for this year's trip. Although we think Chef Mickey's is better, I don't think you would be disappointed with either Chef Mickey's or Cape May Cafe.