Chef Mickey's Dinner vs. Cape May Clam Bake

[KMS'sGlassSlipper]

So right now I'm trying to figure out which one I want to do. I'm on a diet right now, so I'm trying to keep that in mind as well. Which one do you think is better? It's just me and my fiance. We have done Cape May Breakfast. I have always wanted to eat at Chef Mickey's, but I've also heard the bad reviews.

We are APs that live 2 hours away from Orlando, so it's not like we aren't going to be back soon to do one or the other. Just wanted to see which you guys would recommend.

Thanks for your help!!!

 

[stitch09]

cape may cafe for sure!!

 

[Bullseye]

We got free dinig last October and the Cape May Dinner was the best meal the whole trip. The food was great, selection was great, and the deserts were delicious. We were pleasantly surprised. We're going again this June.

 

[Bribrittmom]

I definitely think Cape May for adults.The salad bar and seafood is great.

 

[disneydee6]

100% Cape May. Especially for two adults. They also have a better selection of food. They have a big salad bar (many different kinds of salads to choose from).

 

[casselsshopper]

We just ate at Cape May tonight. The food was fantastic!

 

[jdisnut]

Cape May, no doubt, especially because you are not traveling with children. The food there is considerably better. Chef Mickey's is noisy and chaotic, and the buffet items range from palatable to disgusting.

Cape May is fairly creative for a Disney buffet, and the seafood items are pretty tasty. It's not one of my favorite places on property, but my family typically eats there once every couple trips.

 

[KMS'sGlassSlipper]

Thanks for all the opinions! I'm a sucker for character meals, but DF is not so much! LOL. I think I'm going to try out the clam bake , everything on the menu just looks so much more tasty!!!