I agree with another poster, who said you can have one person who had a bad experience and somebody else was there and loved it. For example we had a less than stellar experience at Minnie's last Monday. Very crowded, very disorganized. Just total chaos, even the cm manager told somebody Ariels was better run as he apologized for the disorganization. When that place gets crowded, it gets crazy! My brother (who was with us) went in January, very off season and they loved it and had a totally different experience. The nice thing about Minnie's is that it is inside the park (same with Ariel's) so you can make a mid to late morning seating, get there early, ride rides, then have breakfast. We have been to Goofy's over ten times and had great character interraction and food each time (breakfast and dinner). I say choose the one that has characters you enjoy. Lilo and Stich was great for us but we love Lilo and Stitch. Storytellers was the most low key character meal I have ever been to which is nice but my nieces hadn't seen Brother Bear or Pocahantas so didn't recognize any of the characters but Dale (Chip was a no show). Goofy's and Minnie's have the widest varieties of characters. Ariel's is nice because its not a buffet which means you don't have to stress you'll miss out on a character while you get your food. But unless you have princess lovers, its not a good choice. There are pros and cons to each but I've had fun at them all (have done them all too) and never left hungry!