You didn't say how many people in your party, and the ages of the kids, if any. You will definitely NOT be disappointed in ASMu. It's a beautiful resort to walk around, and we love it. Assuming you have kids, if they are older, and would spend all their time in the pool on the waterslide if one were there, then I would say definitely go for CBR or another moderate. But if your kids are under 10, do ASMu and spend some of that savings on a couple of extra character meals. The room is not noticeably smaller than the moderates. In fact, the extra bench between the armoire and the bathroom at the moderates actually takes up the space we like for our crib, so we were MORE crowded at POFQ than at the All Stars !