Carrot Cake Cookie or Butterfinger Cupcake?

[rznhal]

Which is a better use of a Snack Credit...the Carrot Cake Cookie or the Butterfinger Cupcake at Hollywood Studios? I have heard good things about both (I'm more about taste than portion Size).. also.. planning on getting the peanut butter cake at Sci Fi for dinner that night, so that may factor in.....?
Thanks!!

 

[Disneyfreak616]

They are both delcious, it all depends on what you like more. The carrot cake cookie tastes just like carrot cake, with delcious cream cheese frosting in the middle which is lovely. The butterfinger cupcake has some white frosting on the outside and is covered in butterfinger pieces, so I would say either pick what you like more, see what you're more in the mood for on that day, or just get both!!

 

[aubriee]

I like both, but if I could only get one I'd go with the Butterfinger cupcake.

 

[nooneshome]

Can't wait to get my first butterfinger cupcake. This is going to be our snack trip.

 

[rznhal]

Thanks everyone! I think i might talk DH into the butterfinger cupcake and get the carrot cake cookie and make him share with me

 

[vllygrrl]

Thanks everyone! I think i might talk DH into the butterfinger cupcake and get the carrot cake cookie and make him share with me

That is exactly what I did in November - they are both HUGE! The cookie and the cupcake both lasted several days in our hotel room. I was a much bigger fan of the cookie - the Butterfinger cupcake was super sweet!