We were considering both for our trip after May 2005 (WAY out planning, lol) that will be just DH and I. We stayed at CBR on our honeymoon and absolutely loved it. After I looked around and read posts about CSR, I don't think we want to stay there. I don't like the way the food court is described, that it's hard to just go in and get a drink refill in the mugs, etc. I looked at the pics of the rooms on allearsnet.com and the decor just didn't suit us. There is nothing wrong with it at all, just not what we like.
Whichever resort you choose, I'm sure you'll have a great time!
Steph