We have gone as a last resort when staying at the Beach Club and been unable to get into Cape May, Yachtsman Steakhouse, Flying Fish or Beaches and Cream.
It is about as vanilla as it gets. The decor is what you would find at any local restaurant and the food, albeit good, is nothing to write home about. There is no "Disney feel" to it at all, which makes it not worth the trip.
I don't see any particular reason to go there if you have other options, especially at Cape May Cafe, by far our favorite resort establishment.
J