Captain's Grille vs Yachtman Steakhouse

[BrittyRo]

Hello all so I'm having trouble figuring out what we are doing on our Epcot day.
Originally I had planned Spice Roads Table Lunch (Candlelight Processional Package) 11:30a [5:00pm CP] and Yachtsman Steak House dinner 6:30pm, however I now saw that we can do CPP with Captain's Grille. I was wondering how different these two restaurants (YSH and CG) were or if we should stick with the original plan?
Which is "better"? It is for our Honeymoon (price isn't a factor). Also is SRT good or do ya'll recommend another TS for the CPP?

 

[Hopefully]

First of all, Congratulations on your upcoming wedding.!!!
Here you are comparing apples and wooden logs. They are nothing alike other than they both serve food.
Yachtsman Steakhouse is an upscale steakhouse in a Deluxe resort. The food is wonderful and the service is superior. Captains Grille is a lower level average hotel restaurant. The atmosphere at Yachtsman in quieter as well. I would definitely stick with Yachtsman for dinner.
We enjoy Spice Road Table very much. We have been twice now. I think it is a good choice for the Candlelight Processional package.

 

[Princess Mulan]

Hello all so I'm having trouble figuring out what we are doing on our Epcot day.
Originally I had planned Spice Roads Table Lunch (Candlelight Processional Package) 11:30a [5:00pm CP] and Yachtsman Steak House dinner 6:30pm, however I now saw that we can do CPP with Captain's Grille. I was wondering how different these two restaurants (YSH and CG) were or if we should stick with the original plan?
Which is "better"? It is for our Honeymoon (price isn't a factor). Also is SRT good or do ya'll recommend another TS for the CPP?

Yachtsman Steakhouse is fine dining with delicious food and excellent service in an upscale setting. It is definitely worth the money for a special occasion! Your original plan sounds great to me!

 

[BrittyRo]

That was my instinct as well. Thank you both for your input!

 

[Scott MC]

Congrats on your upcoming nuptials! We are big fans of YC in general, and prefer CG. I think they try harder. YS is more upscale in food options and decor, but we feel the food is better at CG. I guess my opinion is, if you want an "experience," go for YS. If you want the best food, we recommend. CG.

 

[cluvsdisney]

Definitely YS...everything about it is better than CG.

 

[Uncleromulus]

Yep--YSH outclasses CG in every respect.

 

[OKW Lover]

Between the two choices, there really isn't a question at all. YSH is the better restaurant all around. By far.

We eat there very regularly (two days ago most recently) and always enjoy our meal there. We have a favorite waiter (Oscar) who is always fun to chat with. While there on Tuesday, it was obvious that at least two other tables in that section had specifically requested Oscar as their server. Anyway, the food was great as usual. I had the filet while my wife had the prime rib.

 

[mickeynut1]

Another vote for Yachtsman Steakhouse.

 

[hedberg1661]

Another vote for YS.