We like Cape May a lot. We were last there earlier this year and it was as good as always. They have a lot to choose from but I just get redskin potatoes, corn on the cob, mussels, and clams....once in a while I will have a salad or clam chowder but that's it. And I get lots and lots of it all.....and my wife and daughter do just about the same thing. So I can't really comment about anything else on the buffet but I have always enjoyed the 'basics'.
We were disappointed we could not get there last month but already have plans again to go on our next trip in December....we won't miss it two trips in a row!