Cape May or Cap n Jacks ?

[lrab1126]

What would you pick and why. We like the food on both the menus...so just looking some help on making a decision.

 

[nicolemm]

We had our worst meal of the trip at Cap'n Jacks! It was a shame, when we were younger it was my dad's favorite restaurant, he couldn't wait to eat there! It was all he talked about from the time we booked our trip. There were 14 of us for dinner, only 2 of us liked the food, they both ordered the pot roast. I had the salmon and could smell it from a mile away, it was gross!

 

[girli565]

I had dinner at both places, now if you're into lobster go to Cap n Jacks, but if you have some who are not seafood eaters... I say Cape May, it satisfies the seafood eaters and the meat eater alike.

I prefer Cape May, it's delicious!

 

[banjobears]

I would vote for sure for Cape May Cafe. The last time I at at Cap N Jacks, the food was not that good. I ordered the shrimp with the lobster sauce and it was terrible. The sauce tasted like a mac and cheese sauce. Luckily my server let me choose something else. I had the twin lobster tails, which were good, but not great. The first time I went to Cap N Jack in Feb. 2006, it was great. It's amazing how things change over the years.

Next trip to Disney May 1-8, 2008​

 

[Pirate at Heart]

Jake's is the pits. I would try Cape May.