We ate at Capt Jacks on our last trip (on dining plan, not free though LOL) and we honestly wish we'd eaten there more often during our trip! We only ended up eating there after cancelling other plans because it rained from noon until after 8:30pm! So that evening we ended up at DTD, cancelled our other PS, and went to Capt Jacks because we could use the dining plan there. We found the food delicious. Yes, the wait was long- but they don't take AR's there (atleast that's what I was told at Guest Services and there) and atleast they give you a return time.. instead of just saying sit here and wait for hours. LOL They gave us a return time of 45min later and after we returned it was only about 5min before our name was called. The service was okay, better than some other places we'd eaten during our 10 day trip, and the food was delicious. We got the crab trio and shrimp cocktail appetizers, lobster tail dinners, and the desserts were big and delicious also.
I think it's a way to maximize on the dining plan too- because with 2 adults (1 child eating as adult, 1 real adult LOL) and 1 child- the ticket was over $160 ... but ofcourse we used the dining plan to pay for it. I don't think there are any other meals you can eat at like that -that don't take 2 TS instead of 1? Atleast I haven't found any... that are that costly.