Why don't we think it's a good value? Here's an example -
For 2005, the least expensive room category for the AKL (Pool view in Value Season) costs 29 points for a weeknight (Sun - Thur) and 52 points for a Friday or Saturday night.
Compare that to
DVC accomodations -
OKW studio costs 8 points for a weeknight & 20 points for a weekend night
OKW 1 bedroom costs 16 /40
BCV studio runs 12/22 (same as for VWL,& BWV preferred - these are most expensive DVC resorts)
BCV 1 Bedroom runs 22/45
The seasons aren't quite the same between DVC & the deluxe resorts, but the general concept still applies.
It will always cost more to stay at one of the non-DVC resorts using points than it will to use points to stay at a DVC resort. (If you are thinking of renting points, you'll be better off paying cash and booking directly through Disney in nearly every case).
Except under very special circumstances, most DVC members would choose to stay in a 1 bedroom DVC unit for less points over staying in a standard deluxe hotel room that costs more points.
Anyway, thought a fellow Minnesotan would like a little more info than our standard "trust me, it's not a good value" response.
Best wishes -
P.S. The point cost to stay in non-DVC WDW resort rooms have gone up every year. Point costs for DVC have not.