California Grill, Narcoosse's or Yachtsman?

[Mickey_Man]

Fishy cheescakeYuck.

Thanks again to everyone who voted/commented. Keep it up please.

Seriously - they have to keep those coolers separate or something. We had the cheesecake last summer and it was wonderful - my chocoholic wife said it was arguably the best dessert of her life!! I hope this place hasn't gone downhill.

 

[hmillerbarilla]

Seriously - they have to keep those coolers separate or something. We had the cheesecake last summer and it was wonderful - my chocoholic wife said it was arguably the best dessert of her life!! I hope this place hasn't gone downhill.

It must have been just our experience. But, the cheesecake was HORRIBLE since it really tasted like fish. My mother and sister both agreed, it was very fishy.

A lot of people love Narcoossee's. But, I have to say Cali Grill & Yachtsman were much better on our last trip.

 

[Rudy6]

California Grill is in a class of its own.

The view is wonderful. Be there for the fireworks.

The setting is wonderful. You have room to move around. You are not on top of each other.

The service is top notch.

The food is excellent. The steak is perfect.

Narcoossees is very good.

The view is either of people on the porch or, if there are none to few people, of Seven Seas Swamp. In other words, the view is nothing to write home about.

The setting is fine. Nothing fancy, but nice.

The service is top notch.

The food is very good. The lobster is good. The coffee is excellent - French Press.

I have not been to Yachtsman.

Stick with California Grill.

Have fun,

 

[Ron from Michigan]

California Grill.

 

[Katieinwonderland]

I'll back everyone up and say Cal Grill. OMG DH and I just LOVE this place! I've never had anything I didn't like, I've never had a server that wasn't outstanding and finishing off your meal with Wishes is perfect. I would especially recommend the sushi, it's made fresh and like no sushi I've ever had before.

I like the Yachtsman too, my problem with this location is that it is a steakhouse and I don't love steak, so I struggle to find something really outstanding on the menu for me. It has a very relaxed atmosphere though and the one down side to the Cal Grill is that it gets crowded, especially when Wishes is about to start!

 

[JMD]

My vote goes to California Grill.

 

[tink1957]

California Grill is in a class of its own.

The view is wonderful. Be there for the fireworks.

The setting is wonderful. You have room to move around. You are not on top of each other.

The service is top notch.

The food is excellent. The steak is perfect.

Narcoossees is very good.

The view is either of people on the porch or, if there are none to few people, of Seven Seas Swamp. In other words, the view is nothing to write home about.

The setting is fine. Nothing fancy, but nice.

The service is top notch.

The food is very good. The lobster is good. The coffee is excellent - French Press.

I have not been to Yachtsman.

Stick with California Grill.

Have fun,

Thanks Rudy, Nice breakdown of the facts.

Anyone out there with pics, I would appreciate it.

 

[thesupersmartguy]

We love the Cali Grill, we eat there every night of our trip. Be sure to ask for Beckey. Tell her Super sent you.

 

[tink1957]

We love the Cali Grill, we eat there every night of our trip. Be sure to ask for Beckey. Tell her Super sent you.

Thanks for the tip, I'll be sure to do it.