Butterbeer - Don't believe the hype

[cv1990]

The stuff is disgusting.

 

[Ohiodislover]

I will still try it and form my own opinion. Thanks for sharing yours. Hope it didn't ruin your trip

 

[Magpie]

Each to his own. We loved it!

 

[cv1990]

Horrible stuff

 

[fairyprincess88]

Didn't find it disgusting in the least bit. I love the stuff. I more partial to the frozen but the draft version is amazing too. Can't wait to pack my mug to take back with me in July.

 

[Mamiamjo]

Too bad they don't offer a sugar free version

 

[cv1990]

Would much rather just have it without the 'butter'

 

[ChrisFL]

Would much rather just have it without the 'butter'

hmm, first 3 posts all about butterbeer being horrible...especially odd since butter isn't part of the ingredients at all.

I smell something...

 

[cv1990]

I think my joke went straight over your head. Don't worry about it.

 

[LUVIOA]

We love it! But i think part of the appeal is the uniqueness of the flavor. It is unlike anything else you can get anywhere. Also sitting in Hogmeade while sipping it kind of adds to the magic.

 

[damo]

nom nom nom



ps...there were lots of other butterbeer threads that you could have just added your opinion to, lol

 

[cv1990]

Oh well... one more won't hurt ey

 

[damo]

Oh well... one more won't hurt ey

Yup, that's what I always say when I'm drinking butterbeer.

 

[mesaboy2]

The stuff is disgusting.

Horrible stuff

Would much rather just have it without the 'butter'

So you're saying you didn't like it?

 

[ZellyB]

We love it! But i think part of the appeal is the uniqueness of the flavor. It is unlike anything else you can get anywhere. Also sitting in Hogmeade while sipping it kind of adds to the magic.

We enjoyed it too, but I didn't think it was that unique. I actually thought it tasted a lot like extra-sweet cream soda. I happen to really like cream soda, thus I liked the butterbeer.

But, I've gotta agree that butterbeer minus the "butter" would be my choice most of the time.

 

[RainbowsMist]

I agree....it was nasty BUT I had to have the mug and try it! That being said we only had the non frozen...we weren't offered the frozen. We ended up asking someone and they told us you had to ask for it...

 

[Tink2Day]

Yes but then what would you use to put on your biscuits if you had no butter?
Oops wrong thread....


Actually I think OP is a huge fan of BBeer and just doesn't want to wait in line for it so figures he'll scare others off of it.....

 

[Tink2Day]

I agree....it was nasty BUT I had to have the mug and try it! That being said we only had the non frozen...we weren't offered the frozen. We ended up asking someone and they told us you had to ask for it...

Hmmm imagine that, having to ASK for what you want.....You just got a TM who hadn't finished the mindreading training yet.

SOOOOO happy for those who don't like it! MORE to go around for those of us who do YUM!

 

[LUVIOA]

Yep! One less person in front of me!

 

[damo]

I agree....it was nasty BUT I had to have the mug and try it! That being said we only had the non frozen...we weren't offered the frozen. We ended up asking someone and they told us you had to ask for it...

Here's a picture of the menu at Three Broomsticks. Notice how it is labelled Butterbeer and Frozen Butterbeer.