Bum Genius Diapers...are they really cheaper?

gwtw428

Mouseketeer
Joined
Dec 15, 2003
Messages
363
Hello, I am looking into reusable cloth diapers. I had heard that BumGenius diapers were really great. But after using water, detergent, etc to wash them are they really cheaper than disposbles (huggies, pampers etc)??
Also, how bad is it to clean the cloth diapers? Is it really gross? I heard that you just shake the solids into the toilet then throw into washing machine? I have been watching some tutorials on youtube and to me it really doesnt seem bad. Do the bumgenius diapers get badly stained? Any odors?
Any thoughts on bungenius would be greatly appreciated. Or any other cloth reusable diapers.

Thanks
Jamie
Baby #2 on the way!!!
 
We use Bum Genius pocket diapers for daycare and outings. They are wonderful. We used disposables for about 8 weeks in the beginning and we had more blow outs with them in 8 weeks than in 1 year in cloth.

I breastfed, so in the beginning solids are not solid at all, but water soluable. You can buy a diaper sprayer and hook it up to the toilet, I used the shower sprayer and a bucket in the beginning. You can also just throw them in the washer if you breast feed because it is water soluable.

Once it is more solid, you can shake in the toilet or pull off with a big wad of toilet paper.

I think they are cheaper in the long run. In the beginning, we were going through $40 worth of disposables per week. You can get 3 bum genius for that price and use them from 8-35lbs. It's quite a deal.

We used prefolds and covers in the beginning too and that is what I would suggest. Newborns pee so often, it would be really expensive to buy all those pocket diapers. little-lions.com has them on sale for like $16 a dozen so for $32 you could have 24 diapers and that would get you through 2 days. They cost more when we bought ours, but they are indestructible. If you decide to use prefolds, make sure you buy diaper service quality. The Infant size will last you a long time. This means NO GERBER. They are polyester filled and don't have layers of cotton so they aren't as absorbant at all and don't get quilty after washing. For covers, we like the bummis super whisper wraps. My suggestion would be to use prefolds in the beginning with bum genius for outings or overnight (although you'll be up anyway, so might as well change em).

As far as wash routine goes, I have a small apartment sized washer and it's not that great. I do a cold wash with some squirts of Bac-Out (gets rid of bacteria and stink). Then I do a hot wash with cold rinse using All Free and Clear (about 1/4 of the recommended amount). You want to use less detergent because diapers absorb so much that they can get buildup from the soap and then get stinky. Clean diapers smell like nothing. Also, with detergents you want to look for one that doesn't have additives in it, like brighteners, whiteners, etc. Cheap basic detergent does the job. I like All Free and Clear because it doesn't have scents and then I know the diapers are clean, not just fragranced.

For drying, I throw everything in the dryer except the shells of the bum genius diapers. They are made of PUL which eventually will break down with the heat in the dryer. I throw them in the dryer about once a month to reseal the PUL (which keeps them waterproof).

For a pail routine, I use a dry pail (13 gallon kitchen trash can with lid) with a WAHMies pail liner. It's washable, so I throw it in with the diapers.


Here's some links to sites I've purchased from and used for cloth diapering research:
www.diaperswappers.com
www.clothdiapernation.com
www.cottonbabies.com (the maker of bum genius and they have a sale going on right now)
www.momsmilkboutique.com (free shipping on any purchase, I have bought covers, snappis, pins and diapers from here)
www.greenmountaindiapers.com (I haven't purchased from here, but the prefolds page shows how different prefolds fit different sized babies)
www.little-lions.com (this is where I made my first purchase and bought prefolds, a snappi and some covers)

The thing I love about cloth diapering is that most of the businesses I buy from are run by stay at home moms. I'm not a stay at home mom, but I love that I can help them to be able to stay at home. Also, a lot of cloth diapers (with the exception of indian and chinese prefolds and bum genius sold at target) are made in the USA.

If you have any other questions or want more info, drop me a PM.

ETA: I forgot to comment on staining. The sun is amazing. Any breastfed poop stain, hang the wet diaper in the sun and it's magically gone. You can also spray lemon juice on the wet diaper and sun it and it will help. I've read it works for other stains. I will find out this summer :)
 
OP...I think Lisa M made a lot of the comments I would make about the bumGenius. Here's a little I'll add...

We've tried a bunch out (been cloth diapering for 2 yrs), and my faves are the bumGenius and the FuzziBunz. Both are pocket diapers and the thickness can be adjusted to need (two inserts at night, 1 in the day, etc.).

As for the cost. Depending on how many diapers you buy, the cost can be (and I say can be) as expensive as disposibles. BUT...you can resale cloth diapers. Most good ones have a pretty good resale value...50% or greater. The bumGenius might be around $18 a dipe new, but you can sell ones in good shape on diaperswappers for $10-$15 a diaper. So you can get a good portion of your money back. And if it is for a first child, you can use a good quality diaper for 2-3 kids, so then the diapers are very economical.

Also, your baby may not be in diapers as long as kids in disposibles b/c they tend to potty train earlier (from feeling wetness, unlike many disposibles that still feel dry to the skin when wet). So your child may not be in diapers as long.

I'm sure there is more...but that is what I can think of at the moment.

GL with you decision...
 

Our cloth diapers are on their third baby butt and still going strong. I have a few BumGenius diapers and I like their convenience - they go on just like disposables - but they're expensive and I've had trouble with the elastic losing its stretch on the sides. The nice part was that it fit both my newborn and my 3 year old.

I like prefolds with Bummi Super Whisper Wrap covers. Those are almost certainly less than sposies, last forever, and you can use them for lots of butts if you have more kids down the line.

We have a diaper sprayer that attaches to the toilet and once the baby is eating solids, I can't imagine the diaper routine without it.
 
By prefolds you mean the ones most people use for burp cloths, right?
 
Thanks for all the info! Still alittle confused...What is a prefold? When doubling the thickeness for nighttime do you add 2 pads in the pocket or 1 in pocket and one on top? I saw on youtube this lady put a really thin paper like thing that came on a roll..like toilet paper and she put it on top.
I think this cloth diaper thing is the way to go. I told my husband I wanted to try it and he said it seemed like a good idea and that he was going to love not having to take out dirty diapers to the garbage everyday! lol
 
Hi
Cloth can definitely be overwhelming in the beginning. I once thought I could not do it. I work full time, had 2 boys in diapers and thought no way. But I took the plunge-almost 3 years ago and LOVED it. So much so that I started my own cloth diaper business.

bumGenius are great diapers. They are easy to use and wash. It may take a little time to figure out the right wash cycle for you depending on your water type (hard or soft), how many dipes, etc..
They are definitely cheaper. Cloth diapers require an extra couple loads of laundry each week. I cloth diapered 2 boys on one gallon of detergent. I use Allen's naturally. Put about 1/3 an ounce in each load. A little detergent goes a long way!

Cloth diapers also have good resale value or you can save them for use on subsequent children.

Another great brand is the new Fuzzi Bunz One Size. They are incredibly soft and grow with your baby. You also never have to worry about elastic wear out and sending your dipes out for repair- they have a new design and putting in a new elastic is a breeze and requires no sewing.

Please PM me if you have ANY questions. I own and operate my own Cloth Diaper business so I know a bit about them. ;)
 
Thanks for all the info! Still alittle confused...What is a prefold? When doubling the thickeness for nighttime do you add 2 pads in the pocket or 1 in pocket and one on top? I saw on youtube this lady put a really thin paper like thing that came on a roll..like toilet paper and she put it on top.
I think this cloth diaper thing is the way to go. I told my husband I wanted to try it and he said it seemed like a good idea and that he was going to love not having to take out dirty diapers to the garbage everyday! lol


Gerber makes prefolds that are carried at most Walmarts and Kmarts. They are rectangular in shape, with a thicker panel in the middle. They aren't the best quality, and don't hold a lot, so most people get their prefolds online. Indian prefolds are a good quality prefold, and they come in different sizes (newborn, infant, toddler). You put a cover on those, and they can be pinned with old fashioned diaper pins, or with something much easier called a snappi. Prefolds work good when the baby is itty-bitty...like the first 6 wks or so.

To use a pocket diaper at night, you would put two inserts into the pocket of the diaper. The thin paper thing on the top is a flushable liner...good the first few months b/c it holds most of the solids from the poo. You can just flush that part.

HTH
 
I am probably odd mom out here but I found it to be much cheaper using disposables. There are so many variables to this though. Are you a coupon shopper and bargain hunter? How long will your child wear diapers? Cost of water and electricity?

I had all but about 10 packages of diapers purchased before my son was born. I bought them with coupons and sales and always shopped for the best bargain per diaper price. Never once did it come out to be from costco or sam's.

For me it wasn't a what is easier thing. I still dumped the solids into the toilet as I would with cloth. I did in fact use cloth here and there but never on a regular basis. I am talking just prefolds from walmart with baby pins.

DS was potty trained at 2 yr 7 mo so that plays a huge factor into it. Some kids aren't trained until 4 so that would add a ton of money onto the price of what it will cost you in the end.
 
OP, I started a thread on this a while back, and one thing that was said was not to buy a bunch of one brand of cloth because different brands might fit better or worse on different babies.

How do paper inserts work? I'm so confused. I got some great fitted ones from freecycle and I was like, "What's this little part that looks like a panty liner." PP provided some great links so maybe I can figure it out.
 
By prefolds you mean the ones most people use for burp cloths, right?

Sort of, except most people get burp cloth "diapers" from Babies R Us, gerber brand, and MOST people do not have good luck when using those for actual diapers.

We got good quality "chinese prefold" (though some like "indian prefold" b/c they are longer and less wode) dipes for the beginning from one of the sites, can't recall the name...but not gerber brand.



The laundry is, seriously, so easy. The more complicated I got in washing the rougher things were, and actually the stinkier they were. Until the poops became solid, except for when DS had rota (twice!), I just put the dipes in the wet bag, then washed. I had enough dipes to wash on the third day. Hot wash...sometimes a second rinse. Because of my own allergies and issues dealing with detergent perfume, we ultimately came down to a tablespoon (IF that) of Simple Green with a handful of Washing Soda, and that was that.

One extra wash, every 3rd day.


bumgenius came out towards the end of DS's diapered days, and I really hope we have another kid and I can try out the bgs!
 
They are absolutely cheaper. By a great margin. There is a one time up front cost of about $300 or so and then you are done for the rest of your baby's life. Not only do they cost less but kids in cloth tend to potty learn significantly earlier so you are not in diaper so long. And you can use the same diapers for the next kid.

In addition to being better for your pocket book, they are better for the environment and better for the health of your child. Not only do a lot of the chemicals in the diapers cause rashes for some kids, but the chemicals themselves can cause serious health problems. Here is a good article
http://www.diaperpin.com/clothdiapers/article_diaperdrama3.asp. Some of the chemicals in the diapers are banned in other countries but not in the US due to their carcinogenic potential. In addition, chemicals that were banned in tampons due to their links to Toxic Shock Syndrom are still allowed to be part of the absorbent lining in diapers.

The final super cool thing about cloth is that it is so much cuter! Pretty colors, lacey trim, adorable woolies, pucci prints......
 
All the major bases seem to be covered but I just wanted to add how much I LOVE Charlie's Soap. It was recommended by Fuzzi Bunz but I was unsure of it at first because a gallon was $25. What I didn't realize that you only need 1/16 of a cup for a large load of diapers! My DS is 1 1/2 and we're only on our third bottle and we use it for all of our laundry.

It is unscented and it really gets the diapers clean. I have never had a problem with smelly diapers, I have never rewashed a load and have never used tea tree oil or other products.

The soap is also great for traveling because you use so little of it. On our last vacation I packed some in a small eye makeup remover bottle and it was plenty for all of our laundry.
 
I am probably odd mom out here but I found it to be much cheaper using disposables. There are so many variables to this though. Are you a coupon shopper and bargain hunter? How long will your child wear diapers? Cost of water and electricity?
I'll be the "odd one out" with you.

I bought disposables from a mom who stayed home with her TWO sets of twins (wow!) and had a source for second-quality diapers. Back when I was diapering, I figured up the cost of the good cloth diapers plus covers (which are outgrown and must be replaced), and those seconds were cheaper than cloth -- even without the cost of washing (in hot water). The lady who sold them even delivered to the house; once you became an established customer you could just call her and she'd leave them on your porch.

When you're figuring up the cost of diapering methods, don't forget to include washing extra clothes and bedsheets. You will have more leaks with cloth diapers, and you'll end up washing those other items more frequently.
 
When you're figuring up the cost of diapering methods, don't forget to include washing extra clothes and bedsheets. You will have more leaks with cloth diapers, and you'll end up washing those other items more frequently.

I absolutely do not know a cloth diapering mom who will agree with you on this. What is your source? I cloth diapered three kids and leaks were never an issue for us. I know my friends with disposables had big issues with blowouts but that was not a problem for us, thank goodness.

I would love to know your source for this comment as it runs so counter to my experience and the experience of all of my friends.
 
Add me to the club that has less blowouts with cloth than with disposables (we use both).
 
They are absolutely cheaper. By a great margin. There is a one time up front cost of about $300 or so and then you are done for the rest of your baby's life. Not only do they cost less but kids in cloth tend to potty learn significantly earlier so you are not in diaper so long. And you can use the same diapers for the next kid.

I didn't spent $300 for my son's entire diapering life of 2 1/2 yrs. Guess that is where variables come in.

I do think that kids in cloth probably do potty train much earlier but I really have no evidence to back it up. Just a generalized thought that totally makes sense!
 
I didn't spent $300 for my son's entire diapering life of 2 1/2 yrs. Guess that is where variables come in.

I do think that kids in cloth probably do potty train much earlier but I really have no evidence to back it up. Just a generalized thought that totally makes sense!

How did you not spend $300 on disposables?? I am a total coupon FREAK & don't think I've paid full price on a box a diapers yet. (or formula for that matter) BUT, w/ a big box at BJ's costing about $40 and lasting less than a month...even with coupons, and ONLY spending $30/mth for 36 months (DD was ALMOST potty trained then...) I spent minimum $1080 on 3 years of diapers...and I KNOW I went thru more than one box a month. Now I'm doing it all over again w/ DS.

Share your secret, please...
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom