Think practical! I try to veer away from too much candy because too much candy is --well, too much! So I think summer and spring activities. Things to consider including:
* birdhouse with paints (super cheap to get little wooden birdhouses at Michael's or other craft store and paints there too -- steer clear of yellow which is an attractive color for yellowjackets) -- then you can paint them and hang them up outside.
* butterfly garden (you can reuse the container with new caterpillars and food) or other fun science kits
* movies -- Wreck-it-Ralph which is coming out in March
* bubbles
* swim stuff -- new swim suit, pool toy, puddle jumper, etc.
* outdoor stuff -- pocket disc (crocheted/knit frisbee), frisbee, kite, sidewalk chalk, outdoor game like washers, horseshoes or cornhole, sports items like ball and glove, soccer ball, etc.
* gardening stuff -- tools, fairy garden items, plants, seeds, gardening gloves, watering cans
* arts and crafts -- crayons, arts and crafts supplies, modeling clay (there are small packets at craft stores that are relatively inexpensive and you can make things and bake them hard -- I made a bunch of mini vegetables for a fairy garden basket we're auctioning off at DD's school this weekend)
* I always include a toothbrush -- what can I say, the Easter Bunny is a supporter of dental hygeine! I might consider something like tooth tunes to bring up the fun value.
* summer clothes and accessories -- I love giving fun PJs around this time because it's an easy thing to score on sale. Think flip-flops, sunglasses, hats. some new shorts or skorts with a top.
* reusable water bottles
* luggage -- both of mine need carry-on bags so I'm using this chance to give it to them.