We did a "movie night" party for ds8's birthday in feb. He wanted a sleepover, but a couple of his friends parents hinted that their child wasn't ready for that yet (2nd grade), so I changed it to 5:30-8:30pm and said on the invite for the boys to come in pj's and bring a pillow and sleeping bag for the movie and snacks. We did order pizza, but honestly could have gone without it. I had single serve bags of chips, granola bars, strawberries and grapes, bananas, cupcakes and ice cream bars (I do not scoop ice cream at kid parties!). The biggest hit was the candy bar - each kid got a goody bag with a sports pencil, ring pop, and eraser in it, then they got to use a small ladel to fill their bag with whatever candy they wanted. I put the candy into various bowls/containers and set them up in a "buffet" style arrangement. DS shopped with me and chose the candy, so there were mini kit kat, mini reeses cups, skittles, m&m's, Sour patch kids, jelly beans, gummy worms, junior mints, and whoppers. The kids could eat the candy during the movie or take it home in their goody bag. Most did both. They watched Despicable Me II, and of course started goofing around halfway through it, so we paused the movie and did the candles/happy birthday and opened presents, then put the movie back on. It was perfect timing for a 3-hour party. One friend spent the night, and they went to bed around 10pm. Next morning we did frozen waffles and I drove friend home. I think I spent a total of $70, plus 4 large Little Caesars $5.00 pizzas, which my family ate for dinner, too, so I cant really count all in the total.
My kids have gone to parties where parents have spent hundreds of dollars, and they said all their friends love coming to parties at our house because they get to just hang out. Kids are so scheduled all the time...a good old fashioned "home" birthday party is a novelty these days!!