We ate at both 2 weeks ago. They are both good but would be hard to compare to each other because of their unique differences in ambience and food fare. I think it depends on what type experience you are looking for. The CG has one of the most spectacular views around, and if you plan it right you can make PS around "Wishes," which is what I did. I would compare it towards a more upscale restaurant, but not stuffy. If you want a place to enjoy a romantic dinner, this would be it. Wonderful food, but more expensive, with exquisite view. Boma is a buffet that offers foods with an African flare, although they had a wonderful standing prime rib the night they were there. We thoroughly enjoyed it. All you can eat for a set price. Unique salads and side dishes. Themed interior matching the rest of AKL. Persons who greeted us (in full costume) were later performing with drums and dancing...very entertaining. You wander, at will, from station to station gathering food, so you will be up and about, helping yourselves throughout the evening. If I had to make a choice between the two, however, it would have to be CG. Talk about magic. Wonderful food and service with the castle full view our first night there. And, it really was a treat feeling pampered after walking around the park all day..... Can't wait to go back. Good luck with your decision, hope this helps.