Boardwalk Inn

[Tonyspad]

My vote is for the Poly.
We just finished a stay at the BWI and we did not care for it. The location and Boardwalk access is nice BUT... The rooms are dated. it is a very long walk to the themed pool, there is not a quick service spot in the hotel, plus, plus , plus.

The Poly is completly refurbished, easy transportaion to Epcot and the MK plus the grounds are beautiful

 

[AshleyMWC]

For me, comparing BWI and Poly is like comparing apples to oranges. Both are awesome in their own rights. They have totally different feels about them, but I find both very relaxing! For me, the Poly has the feel of the Magic Kingdom excietment, while the BWI has more of a Great Gatsby excitement feel. You can't go wrong with either one!!!!

 

[Hoopfamily]

We stayed at the BWI OCT 2006. HATED IT.


The only thing we liked was the close proximity to Epcot. Other than that thumbs down all the way. Transportation to the parks was slower than slow. There is not a place to eat IN the BWI. The night time stuff isn't that great, and after you do it once you realize it's very mundane. The kind of stuff you came to disney hoping not to see.
Never stayed at the Poly but here's to hoping it's better.