We sailed on the old StarShip Atlantic about 11 years ago. Not long after that Disney announced that they would have their own line. We still haven't made a voyage on the new ships. I would be interested to hear from anyone who has been on both. Was there anything about the Big Red Boats that you prefered to the new ships? Or do the new ships put the old ones completely to shame?
I was on SSOceanic in 1990 and SSMajestic sailing to the Abacos in 1992. I just went on the 7 Day Western Cruise on the Magic on 8/17.
Although I do not bash Premier and have fond memories of my cruises on the Big Red Boat, I can honestly say that there was nothing I preferred over Disney.
Some people have pointed out that there may have been more food choices on
DCL's menu, but we felt that there was plenty of excellent food selections choose from. The Magic does not have the nightly midnight buffet (except for a dessert buffet one night on the 7 day cruise), but I often thought that the midnight buffet was a waste and just another excuse to shove in 5,000 extra calories. And Premier didn't have Palo! Ah! .....memorable daydream in process.....
The shows were far superior and there were more of them - family game shows, adult cabaret shows, themed "party" nights, quiet musical interludes in the lounges, big production numbers, etc.
I remember how bored we were on Premier the night we were in Nassau. We had a little one with us, and basically the whole ship was "closed" - no shows, no kids programs unless you had signed up for babysitting, etc. I remember my husband went to sleep early, I stayed at the wading pool with my 4yo and my 11 year old just wandered around the ship bored. That would NOT happen on Disney. With the exception of the ship's stores, all programs are still up and running when the ship is in port.
I felt servers and stateroom host/hostesses were very good on Premier but the cast members on the Magic were.........Disney, what else can I say?
Although my "little one" turned 17 a couple of days after we disembarked a few weeks ago, he thoroughly enjoyed Common Grounds. From all that I've heard/seen, the kids programs on DCL are far superior to anything that PCL had.
Even though the Magic is much bigger than the Oceanic (BRB's largest), the layout and directional signs were much more convenient. The staterooms on the Oceanic were considered very large at the time, but of course the Magic's staterooms' layout and size are much better. The option is there for a verandah - which I would very much recommend if possible.
What really struck me was the difference in width in the ships. There was just so much more room to move around up on the sun deck and sports deck. And of course, nothing can beat the wonderful promenade deck on 4 with those incredibly cozy padded loungers!
I have to say that all 3 cruises provided breathtaking private islands. Salt Cay and the island Premier used in the Abacos were just as spectacular as
Castaway Cay. I was a little surprised to see that.
Just like the Disney Parks, with every glance and turn you can see little Disney "gems" - the themed uniforms of the crew, the art work, hidden Mickeys, the choice of music playing, etc.
So although I do not believe Disney put Premier "to shame", I feel I can safely say that if you enjoyed your Premier Cruise, you will positively "rave" about
Disney Cruise Line.
Ruth