Well, you threw in the "cute" requirement which really doesn't go well with the request for best Disney shoes. Honestly, I've given up on my shoes looking remotely cute while there. Comfort is the priority. I usually bring tennis shoes and Keens. I will only wear the tennis shoes on days that aren't calling for rain (which is rare). Nothing is worse than having sopping wet tennis shoes. Keens are perfect, because they have the cushion of a tennis shoes while being made from neoprene. If your feet get wet, you aren't misereable. They dry quickly.