being a scallops fiend myself I can say My most favorite scallops are from Narcossis.
Runner up is from flying fish followed by Yachtmans Steakhouse (appetizer at yachtmans)
As always, UncleR has the accurate information. I'm going to bluezoo again next month and I'm thinking of just getting 2 of these appetizers for my meal. Yes, they are that good.
We had outstanding scallops at Artist Point. We enjoyed the preparation more at AP than at FF, but the preparations vary very frequently, and what tastes better is so much a matter of personal taste. I'd say the quality of the scallops was equal at both restaurants.
The scallop dish that was the best I have EVER had was the pan seared scallops at Le Cellier, last Sept. I don't remember the exact description but golden beets were part of the dish and the scallops were cooked to perfection. I looked forward to having it again when we returned in April and I was crushed when it was no longer on the menu.
The scallops I had at Narcoossee's were amazing but after reading the post about Citricos I hope they have them when i go bause I will definetly get them