Best Place to celebrate DD's 2nd Birthday?

[SewSweetMama]

My dd will be turning 2 October 8th and we will be in wdw through 10/5. We want to order a small cake and celebrate in Disney fashion

Here are our ADR's... which would be the best place to do the cake? I was thinking Coral Reef on our last day since I thought she would get a kick out of the aquarium, but I have seen mixed reviews about it on the board. Thanks!!

1. Boatwright's - 7:10pm
2. Whispering Canyon - 5:25pm
3. Akershus Storybook - 7:00pm
4. Biergarten - 4:00pm
5. Boma - 6:00pm
6. Coral Reef - 3:00pm
7. Les Chefs - 2:00pm
8. San Angel - 2:00pm

 

[Dizneydaz]

I would do it at PSB if you can. We've been to WDW a few times over DD's birthday but we've never ordered a cake. many of the restaurants will do something special without you ordering it but you can't count on it.

A few years ago DD enjoyed her special treatment at Brown Derby so much that she wants to return there for her birthday this year. I did tell her that it may not be the same. We've gotten personalized desserts at Brown Derby, RR, CG, and more. When I say personalized I mean they said Happy Birthday but not with her name.

At PSB the last time we were there near her birthday she got to wear a cape and hold a sceptor (sp?). We had to give them back. Also all the staff signs a birthday card as well. Since almost everyone there is having a special celebrattoin I don't know if they are still doing it.

If it was me I would tell every restaurant you booked you are celebrating. Hopefully 1/2 of them will do something.

Here's the special cake she got a few years back at HBD

 

[SewSweetMama]

Thanks for that info! I wasn't sure if it was ok to add it to every ADR, but you're right, it wouldn't hurt. I was thinking of ordering a regular cake, but that little cake is adorable and would be perfect for her