Best Key Lime Pie on WDW Property?

[J-Dog]

Hi all!

I realize that if I want "real" Key Lime Pie, I need to head south of WDW and Orlando, but it's kind of our tradition to try at least one Key Lime Pie place when we go to FL.

On our next trip, we are planning to go off-site to a place called Sister Honey's, but are also interested in seeing if Disney has any offerings.

Mostly looking at Disney Springs, but somewhere in the Parks, or maybe even at a resort would be worth checking out.

Any opinions? Thanks!

 

[jsbowl16]

I am no Key Lime expert but we had it at Wine Bar George and really enjoyed it with pretty much everything else we get there.

 

[Davev77]

We loved the mile high key lime pie at Sebastian’s over at CBR, I’m not an expert either but we loved it so much we went back another night to have it. I’m not sure if they still offer it since they changed to a family style meal.

 

[HiStitch626]

Sister Honey's is good, although they do make their Key lime pie with whipped cream instead of meringue. However, they do use Key limes and their pie is nice and tart. I cannot recommend any of the pies on property as they tend to add things to the pie that don't belong there - a good Key lime pie should only have three ingredients. The best I have had on property, and this is not really a recommendation, is at the Grand Floridan Café.

 

[2xcited2sleep]

Boathouse (Disney Springs) has a key lime pie they serve in a mason jar. I've not tried it personally but others at our table really loved it. Really fun restaurant with a varied menu. We really love sitting outside (weather permitting) and watching the boats. Wine Bar George is my other favorite Disney Springs spot ... didn't know they had it on the menu as we never make it to dessert due to everything else we eat, but WBG is consistently excellent.

 

[MATTERHORN]

I just had an amazing Key Lime Pie at Grand Floridian Cafe last week! It was so good that I'm thinking of going again just for that!!!

 

[AllisonLB1994]

Olivia's at Old Key West has an amazing key lime pie

 

[beccasmom]

Olivia's at Old Key West has an amazing key lime pie

Totally agree - incredible!

 

[J-Dog]

Thanks to everyone for the advice!

I had heard about the Key Lime Pie in a Jar at the Boathouse - my buddy's review was good but it seemed kind of gimmicky to me. Will probably try it, though.

Also might have to check out Olivia's. That wasn't even on my radar but got 2 votes here.

Thanks so much!

 

[AnnaS]

I have had it at the Boathouse and Olivia's - really enjoyed both.

 

[easyas123]

They used to serve a Key Lime Pie wine at the Springs margarita place. That was soooo good!

 

[Lizgistix]

We've only had Key Lime Pie at Grand Floridian Cafe and I think Coral Reef(?). They were nice, but dialed down for out-of-state tourists. We like Key Lime Pie on the tart side and the ones we've had thus far have been mild or more on the sweet side, compared to at home.

 

[Disneypapa]

Another vote for Olivia's at Old Key West. Yum Yum