No offense Earl lover's, but I too like Earls....but when wanting something different and more than just a sandwich, I have to say the best (IMHO) CS in WDW is no other than...........
We love Earl but on our last trip we did WGP Express & I had the Chicken Thai Noodle Salad Oh my it was so good & free refills on my Brewed iced Tea. There pizz are very good also. I do not think you can go wrong with either WGP or Earls.
Put down another mark for Earl of Sandwich. DH and I ate there on our last trip on friends recommendations. They didn't steer us wrong, it was great. Only bad thing, if I remember correctly everything is ala carte.
We go to WDW pretty often, and while we do try to vary our dining choices for the most part the ONLY place where we consciously plan on eating every time is the Earl of Sandwich.
Wolfgang Puck Express is good, sure (I love their garlic mashed potatoes) -- but the Earl has had my vote since my first bite of a Full Montague.
Another vote for Earl! My husband is very picky and he won't eat any sandwiches on their menu. So I ask for just bread, turkey, and cheese for him, and there's never any problem.
I guess it depends what your in the mood for. Earl and Wolfgang are the best in DTD. We always eat at Wolfgang because it has something for everyone in the family. We have eaten at Earl and loved it also. I would wait to decide until your actually in DTD.
I vote for Earl over Wolfgang. The sandwiches are soooo good.
If you are not on the DDP though... another good suggestion would be Bongo's walk up. They have empinadas for 75 cents and potato rellenos and ham crouquets for 50 cents I believe. Good fried cuban food really cheap!