best cruise line for adults?

[mmmbop]

Please bare with me.

We have five adults. Three in one room, two in another. Hoping to head to Bahamas Feb 2016.

MIL, FIL & SIL in room #1. Mom and dad have cruised before (Carnival). When asked about their experience, they said they were bored. It was only a four or five nighter to Eastern Caribbean.
SIL had never sailed.

Hubby and I have done DCL together and loved it. The only disappointment we had was that it wasn't longer. We left parts of the ship unexplored. Too much fun!!!

About 15 years ago, my family sailed NCL and I really can't say anything bad about it. But again, it was 15 years ago.

We had our own plans for vacation in 2016, but that was smashed by the in laws but I digress...

when talking about it, it seems to have been narrowed down to a cruise on Carnival Victory, a Sovereign class ship on RCCL and (probably thrown out there to appease me and not really an option) DCL Magic.

As I said, hubby and I are 100% team DCL. My ILs are wishy washy. SIL is worried she will be inundated with kids on DCL & worried about room size. In laws get bored easily.

What line do you think will be best for us?

 

[PrincessShmoo]

worried about room size.

You can point out that DCL rooms, when compared to a similar category room on most other cruise lines are larger.

We've done DCL, Carnival, Holland America, and Princess. All as adult-only trips. Not gotten bored on any of them yet.

Remind them that the kid's clubs on DCL seem to keep the kids pretty well occupied, and, unlike other cruiselines (our experience) the adult-only venues are ADULT-ONLY on DCL. CMs do a great job keeping it that way.

 

[jack87891]

we've done RCL and Disney with just adults. we continue to choose Disney on future cruises because of the service. it's a cut above. the adults only areas on the ship are nice and quiet. Serenity Bay is a great place to just hang out. We just like it a lot.