My two favorites are Columbia Harbour House and Pecos Bill, but it really depends what you're up for! CHH has wonderful seafood options (fish baskets, shrimp baskets, chicken) and Pecos Bill is more burgers/fries.
Cosmic Rays and Pinocchio Village Haus are also pretty good. I believe Cosmic Rays is also burgers/sandwiches, but I can't remember much about Pinocchio's.