Well, just an update to this thread.
We do not like the way we have been assigned rooms since the "Room Ready" policy has been in effect. On our last visit at the end of October we had to complain to get one request met, upper floor, and we could not get the Epcot side. At least it was non-smoking, which shouldn't even be a request. I had said earlier that I'd sell if we got stuck in a 1st floor pool side, which is where they tried to put us, so we decided to sell the BCV points and maybe purchase later if things change back to the way they were.
The trip itself was great and we love Disney, but we did not buy at BCV to see the driveway out of the windows. If we are going to make reservations at 11 months out we believe our requests should be met more often. Maybe our expectations were too high, but the first year or so was great until the room assignment policy was changed. It was not fun any more checking in and getting the complete opposite of what we requested, it takes a bit away from the Disney Magic when the room is not even close to what you expected. I don't even know why they take requests when they just assign the first room available, requests don't matter anymore. We've never had a problem getting requests met at any of the Disney hotels in the past, so spending the extra money to do that will make our stay that much more enjoyable.
I hope the new owners enjoy it as much as we did our first few trips in the first year of ownership. Back then requests made 11 months out were more important than someone complaining their room's not ready at 9am.