I have been tossing these two around, too, for our October trip. My children are dd9 and twin ds15. My dilemna has to do with marina access. At the Poly, the boys can't drive the water mice. They can at the bc, but I'm not sure the bay is all that great there. I'm starting to even think about whether we should consider POR because I know they love the marina there. Problem is MOM really wants to go Poly or BC. What do you think?