Our first on-site vacation at WDW is coming up in just over a month!! We (me, hubby, sons (4 &1) and my parents) are staying in a dedicated 2 bdr at BCV. So I knew (from spending enough time here on the DIS) that requesting a specific room number is not a good idea when making a reservation. My only requests were to not be on first floor, non-handicapped, and non-smoking. But if we are given a choice at check-in ("you are in this room here, or we also have this room available" - which I have read has happened to people), I won't know which one is better. So... if you have stayed in a dedicated 2bdr at BCV and loved your room (whether it be because of the condition of the room, view, location to elevators, etc., please give me the room number and what you loved so much about it. That way, if given a choice, I will be an informed DISer and be able to pick a great one! Thanks so much! 

OKW on the other hand utilizes "room ready" where they basically give you the choice of what is ready and available at check-in. If you check in before 4pm (official check-in time for DVC)...if there are rooms available, they will give you a choice of rooms in the catagory you've booked and that may or may not fit your requests. (if you check in earlier than 4pm they give you a choice of "these are what's available right this minute or you can wait until 4 and we can put you here"). In any case, since BCV's doesn't utilze "room ready" you will most likely be given a room assigned prior to checking in so put your requests in when you book
). We've had all 3 at one point or another and liked our 3rd floor 1bdrm villa with pool view the best so far -- followed by the courtyard view studio on the 2nd floor we had once. Didn't much care for the 5th floor studio we had with the Epcot view as there was alot of noise from the service road that it also overlooks and didn't really see the fireworks from our balcony because we were always in the park to see them. FWIW too, we didn't have any trouble with noise from the pool view... but we may have just had more considerate neighbors that trip. I'd just put in your most important requests like "non-smoking" or "near the elevators" or whatever. Most locations are pretty good at this resort I'd say.