Bankruptcy... do too many people take the easy way out?

Papa Deuce

<font color="red">BBQ loving, fantasy football pla
Joined
Sep 29, 2003
Messages
17,783
OK, hoping this doesn't get ugly, but based on the 2 people I know who have declared bankruptcy ( one was a former GF ), it seems like too many people are all too willing to declare banruptcy. Then I read this:

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story2&u=/ap/20050310/ap_on_go_co/bankruptcy

Now I know that bankruptcy isn't a panacea ( one of my few college words ), but for most cases I think it is too easy to take this way out.

And I am not unsympathetic to those who have been overwhelmed by factors beyond their control. The two people I know, though, brought it on themselves.

I hope it becomes MUCH HARDER to declare bankruptcy. With life in general, IMO, it seems like in the last 10 - 20 years, too many peple do not want to take blame and responsiblity for self created problems.
 
I only know one person personally who has declared and he declared it for a business he started that failed. For the type he declared he paid most of it back. It still haunts him to this day.

I don't know how easy it is. But I really think people should have a good reason to be declaring. Medical expenses that got out of control that you have no control over, fraud on your accounts, and failed businesses are really the only ones I can think of. And I think for a failed business and medical expenses, you really ought to pay as much of it as you can. Fraud is different. Usually with fraud, someone else rang up debt in your name.
 
I agree with you. I can see it happening when a medical emergency comes up....we all know how quickly the money goes when doctors are involved! There are situations that just happen that is life, but when you get yourself into so much debt because you feel that you deserve a certain level of lifestyle, well ya know, sometimes you just have to pay the fiddler if you want to dance. There is a name for it. Instant Gratification. I tease my husband because he gets it BAD sometimes and I just have to slap him back to reality. :cool1:
 
The two people I know (and one is a relative :sad2: ) filed due to racking up too much credit card debt (over $20K) and other bills that were due to "wants" and not "need" - big TV's, computers, cool toys and vacations. Like a big SUV payment over $600/month - he decided he didn't want to pay anymore, he just let the finance company come take it back, but didn't want to be responsible for the remaining money due. It does infuriate me when people do this - they are forgiven thousands of dollars of debt because they SPEND TOO MUCH $$$! It's called living within your means. And we all pay the price when people don't.

Sorry to ramble, but I do hope they tighten the bankrupcy laws a lot and start making people responsible for their actions.

Failed businesses and huge medical bills are a different story, I can empathize with that.
 
I just read an article recently that said over 1/2 of all personal bankruptcy was "health related" Where people get overcome by catastrophic health expenses. I have sympathy & empathy for these & think they need the help. You should not lose everything because you get cancer.

On the other hand, a health insurance company should not be able to dump you at a whim, and accesibilty to health insurance should be easier (somehow, someway). Maybe a lot of bankrupcies would be avoided if this were the case.

On the other hand (again), if a person goes out and gets a bunch of credit cards, fills them up buying toys & living beyond their means, they should not get a "free pass". Their actions are fradulent & IMHO, borderline illegal.
 
I filed, when my marriage ended, the ONLY way I was able to support my children on my own was get out from under the debt that my Ex's drug habit racked up! I was a SAHM and had NO income, NO car, NO home. Had to file to get on my feet and "out of debt" to start new. And I didn't have a Credit Card until AFTER I filed.
 
I only know one person who has filed and from my understanding they are paying it all back. I don't know what "Chapter" it is but they make monthly payments and are paying it all back. I have no problem with that if that is what they need to get back on track. It isn't a "free pass".
 
I agree that it is acceptable when people are overwhelmed with medical bills and I pray for people in those situations. However as a lender most of the bankrupt situations we see can be prevented and are brought on by people wanting to have things early in life that most people aren't able to have early on. Now if you are blessed at an early age and are able to pamper yourself with these things then that is truly wonderful and well deserved. We see alot of younger couples, my age in fact, that borrow and blow. My BIL and SIL are among this bunch. For some reason it was more important for them to have their children wear Ralph Lauren clothes than to pay their mortgage and they declared Chapter 7, the kind you don't pay back. Luckily they were able to keep their house but it could have been an even worse situation all brought on by selfishness.

I would advise anyone who is considering this to think twice it affects your credit score for a very long time. While people are getting out of this massive debt that they have it causes more harm than good.
 
Yes, I think many take the easy way out. In our lifetime of ups and downs in construction business, we have been what you might call financially bankrupt several times, but never declared. Learned and figured it out the honest way w/o a scapegoat. There are those that may have factors beyond their control and do deserve a second chance. However, we know people living beyond their means, have taken the easy way out, declared, and continue their bad spending habits. :rolleyes:
 
it seems like too many people are all too willing to declare banruptcy.
Based on the story I saw regarding bankruptcy, more than half are due to medical bills from catastrophic illness. Less than 10% are due to people going out and running up their credit cards knowing that they can easily declare bankruptcy and get out of their obligations.

Like the stories you hear about people on welfare buying steaks with food stamps, the stories about personal bankruptcy seem to be more legend than fact.

Another interesting thing about the story I saw.....the current law congress is about to pass will limit personal bankruptcy even for those who had no control over their circumstances,but it leaves open plenty of loopholes for the wealthy.

Not surprising at all.
 
I used to do creditor's rights law and a lot of the debtors used bankruptcy as a way to avoid their debts. One lady had filed 3 times in the last 5 years. I think there should be a limit. So, you make some bad decisions and bankruptcy is there to help you out. You learn and don't do it again. Fine. It shouldn't be something that you can do over and over again.

As for medical bills....I'm torn about this. Did the person's employer offer benefits that they refused because they didn't want to pay a contribution? If so, then I don't think they should be able to discharge it. They chose to be uninsured. Yeah, it stinks having money taken out of your check every week, but you pay car insurance and homeowners insurance, so why not health insurance? If they work and their employer doesn't offer benefits and they get shut out of the government programs like medicaid and free care, then I think they should be discharged after a certain point and I don't think that should negatively impact their credit.....maybe create a special bankruptcy chapter for medical debts that doesn't ruin their credit.

Many of the people I dealt with were forced into Chapter 13. They couldn't get out of paying the debt, the court restructured the debt for them so they paid it off in monthly installments to avoid litigation. Bankruptcy doesn't always mean they get a free pass with their debts.

I also have problems with the lenders who were our clients. When you see that someone filed for bankruptcy a year earlier, why do you give them another loan for $20,000?? Why do you give them a home loan? When you see that someone had a car repossessed recently, why do you give them an auto loan? I definitely think the lenders have some responsibility. Many times I've wanted to tell the client that they made their bed, now lie in it. You give money to someone who has shown an inability or unwillingness to pay in the past, now you want ME to get it back?? Yeah....I don't do that kind of law anymore.
 
My SIL's next door neighbors have filed twice! They are the all american looking family who look like they have it all only problem is they don't pay for any of it. They're living in a beautiful brand new home, driving brand new cars and going into debt again. They've never had medical bills or circumstances beyong their control it's all done delibratly to milk the system. They actually brag that they've gotten away with it twice and said they will again.
 
As for medical bills....I'm torn about this. Did the person's employer offer benefits that they refused because they didn't want to pay a contribution? If so, then I don't think they should be able to discharge it. They chose to be uninsured. Yeah, it stinks having money taken out of your check every week, but you pay car insurance and homeowners insurance, so why not health insurance?

I believe in the article these people are siting it was referring primarily to people with medical insurance who were wiped out after hitting their insurance maximum or because of things their insurance would not cover. Someone correct me if I'm wrong.

I know 2 people who have filed bankruptcy and it did not seem to be an easy out. One was my parents due to my moms failing health, medical bills and her going on disability, and another was a single mother who was hit with a $50,000+ assessment on her condo due to faulty construction. She later sued and got the money back but it took 3 years by which point she'd already had to file to save her home.

I agree some changes to the system could be made, but I do not like the new law they are suggesting at all.
 
One lady had filed 3 times in the last 5 years


It's my understanding that a person can only file once every...is it 7 or 8 years?

I don't see how anyone could file every 18 months or so.

Had the Republicans allowed the exemption for those who were filing due to catastrophic illness or had they allowed for the loophole to be closed that allows wealthy entities to divulge themselves of their assets in order to claim bankruptcy, I would have been all for it.
 
palmtreegirl said:
My SIL's next door neighbors have filed twice! They are the all american looking family who look like they have it all only problem is they don't pay for any of it. They're living in a beautiful brand new home, driving brand new cars and going into debt again. They've never had medical bills or circumstances beyong their control it's all done delibratly to milk the system. They actually brag that they've gotten away with it twice and said they will again.

These types of incidents are sickening. Likewise a person I know of who has filed bankrupcy and has a couple of vacations scheduled for 2005. What is wrong with people?

I fully support the revamp that is in Congress and would support something more aggressive/less forgiving.
 
As some of you remember, we filed in September when DH's business finally couldn't do it anymore. I supported us most of last year (including months before the business closed as we tried to hang on) on my teaching salary. I had signed on one big loan so I had to file as well so we didn't lose our home. We're not proud of it, but I didn't want to be living in a "van by the river". We've hung on by our fingernails all winter trying to get back to "normal" and hopefully DH's new job starting today will lead us down that path. But we sure don't have Disney on our mind until 2006. If we go anywhere this year we'll just go visit DH's sister in NC.
Robin M.
 
I know a family who filed.... at the time they had a 4 year old, a 2 year old and a newborn... they filed and within 2 years they bought a new van, had another baby, are talking about getting a suburban to pull their new camper, took the whole fam damily to Disney World and are building a 5 bedroom 3 bathroom house. :confused3
 
bought a new van, had another baby, are talking about getting a suburban to pull their new camper, took the whole fam damily to Disney World and are building a 5 bedroom 3 bathroom house.
It is easy enough to get credit cards and even purchase cars on credit after filing bankruptcy, but not a chance you'll be able to do things such as get a mortgage for what sounds like a very expensive home.

Perhaps you don't know all the private details of their financial situation and their source of money. Either that or they fall into that category that won't be affected by the new bankruptcy bill.

There are ways to protect your assets before filing bankruptcy under the current laws and this bill does nothing to stop that abuse. For the most part, this bill makes it more difficult for middle income people to declare bankruptcy, even when their debt was incurred for reasons beyond their control.

The poor (who don't have credit cards, SUVS and mortgages) and the wealthy are still protected.
 
I work for a lender and we are part of an association that lobbied HEAVILY for bankruptcy reform. The problem with any legislation is that people are going to get through for whom it's not intended, and people are going to get caught for whom it's not intended. There is a means test established in this legislation that gives the court jurisdiction to determine what you can pay back and what you can't. Obviously a family making $45k who racks up $200k in medical bills is different from a family making $150k who racks up $200k in credit card debt.

As far as why lenders make loans to people who have declared bankruptcy... because it's a good market. People who have declared cannot be automatically prime again. Someone has to serve them, and that's where sub-prime lending comes in. Interest rates are higher (by a good bit) and many people are successful translating a judgement into good, stable credit in a number of years. If the sub-prime product didn't exist people wouldn't qualify for credit again and that would be a problem (ie, obtaining a mortgage, a car loan, consumer credit). Not to mention, if you serve the sub-prime market, you have to serve the ENTIRE sub-prime market or you have "community" groups suing you constantly on the grounds that you are not making the loans fairly (and when I say "fair" I don't mean based on credit worthiness).

Anyway, that's about all I can say on the issue from work. I'll try to catch up later at home.

Erin :)
 
I'm not thrilled with the law as proposed, but it is a start.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom