I was just wondering how they get surprised - definitely not hoping to get something for free (altho sometimes free is nice too!) I guess what I was asking was whether it mattered if you were renting points from someone. I have a reservation for the Coral Reef restaurant with a personalized menu & diver and would have been more than happy to pay for those! If I decide I really want something special in the room for my GS, I will definitely search online to see what is offered & not just hope for some Disney magic