The first list is about what I buy before school minus the calculator and we don't pay attention to the seperate binders for each subject. I know my kids and one big binder with 5 subject categories works best for all my kids so I just ignore the request for seperate binders. I do wish we even got a list while things were still on sale. One of my kids was super into getting each and every item on the list but that has calmed down as she has realized you don't really use all the items and most of it is gone bey winter break and I just fill the necessaties. To me it is just a requested list at this point ih my kids careers. We know what works best for our kids more then theet school does. Now from time to time throughout the year there will be certain must haves for each class, my kids will let me know at that point what is a must have. I am not sure if I will have to buy the calculator this year or not? My going into 8th grader is going to be in geomatry and I can't remember if you need it or not?