We actually just got back from picking things up at Babycakes out here in LA!
The only thing I really have not liked is the Red Velvet cupcake. I find it way too dry for me. Also, I usually take off most of the frosting from the cupcakes....I find it way too sweet.
Otherwise, I have had:
the cupcakes (various flavors)
donuts
macaroons
black and white cookies
Thin Mints
Brownies
I do like the cookies, but I am only allergic to eggs and nuts so I just prefer to make my own cookies at home. Its not that difficult and its not worth the $1.50/cookie to buy them there