My DW and I ate there last August, and we both had the wine pairing option. Since your DH isn't much of a wine fan, I wouldn't bother with the extra expense ($16), but for us it's a must since we both enjoy good wines. AP's wine selection is a bit limited since they primarily feature Northwest wines, but the selection they do carry has some excellent wines, featuring some of the top names from Oregon and Washington.
When our server came back to take our wine flight order, we were still undecided, so she brought out four samples--all gratis--to help us make up our minds. That's what I call superb service. I wound up having the buffalo which was good (honestly, I've had better; then again, I lived in Alaska for four years where it can be found on many fine restaurants' menus)--my DW thought it was very good. The wine suggestions by our server, in concert with our sampling, were spot on. Our salads, appetizers, and desserts were all good, though I'd give the edge to the berry cobbler over the coffee two ways (creme brulee & bread pudding). The French press coffee served table side is notable.
Overall, the service was outstanding, the food excellent, and the ambience very nice. For a more romantic meal, I would suggest going a little later so that the groups with younger kids will be thinned out a bit. After dinner, stroll around WL: past the geyser to the docks (you can see fireworks from there), around by the Hidden Springs Pool, and even on down the trail toward Fort Wilderness. I'm sure you will enjoy the experience at AP. Enjoy!