Hi, Chrissy,
I hope this helps and doesn't confuse you. So, here goes:
I book my trips directly through CRO. Room only. In July of 1999, I booked May 2000 and was able to get a Disney Club Discount (10% off rack rate during regular season). The Annual Passholder rates for May 2000 came out in March 2000. (AP rates are released a few months at a time). I was then able to get 2 of my 8 nights at the AP rate (it was for the GF, so it was a good savings). They also had an AP discount for the Contemporary for the last 3 nights of my stay. So I took them and we changed hotels during the stay.
I believe the AP discount at that time was 30%. Once I secured the hotel rates, I then bought the actual Annual passes. The passes themselves are expensive. I remember that the difference in the passes I was planning to get (Length of stay which was 9 DAYS so they were alot) and buying APs was only $25.00, so it was worth it in that regard. Check out the ticket prices on mousesavers. Your room savings would have to exceed the price difference in the tickets you would originally plan to purchase. Did I lose you yet?
We returned again in May 2001, one week before the AP expired. We stayed at the CR and I believe I was only able to get 3 of the 6 nights at the AP rate. They were sold out by the time I called. I have to say we got our money's worth out of the APs.
Just yesterday, I booked my trip for next June. I was able to get a AAA discount which was 10% off the Polynesian and 15% off the Caribbean Beach Resort. I am planning on buying 7 day park hopper passes. Using a AAA discount, that would cost me $1,160.00. Annual Passes would cost me (with AAA discount) $1,355.00. A difference of apx. $200.00. So, when the AP rates come out next spring, I would have to save at least $200.00 off the rooms to break even.
Also, I have never had any problems modifying my ressies when I secured the new discounts.
Hope this helps!!
Anna