Are the filets really disappearing?

shyjade

DIS Veteran
Joined
May 15, 2006
Messages
4,350
For those you you who have recently been to Disney, or are going in the near future, please tell me...are the filets really being taken off the menus?!

Rumor has it the filet is already gone from Kona...

Please tell me this is all a bad joke?! :scared1:
 
The filet was not on the menu at Brown Derby in May when I was there. The popular websites with menus were still showing that it was available. I was so disappointed.
 

The maple filet is gone from Le Cellier. The mushroom filet is still there. I was able to order it without the mushrooms and truffle sauce and with cream cheese mashed potato. It was as close to the maple filet as I could get! ;)
 
What?!?! That is ridiculous!! That is why I go to Kona!! I don't often get to eat Filet, that is part of vacation, what are they thinking?
 
I think who ever is in charge of disney dining should be fired! One bad decision after another! If this is true it is crazy!
 
I'd be very surprised if filets are removed from the World's restaurants.
 
They should just add a surcharge if you want a filet rather than get rid of it maybe add $2. or something. I hate when the menus change before free dining. They hsould have 180 days before to set the menu like we do!
 
Menus change all the time at restaurants not just at Disney. Chefs like to try new things or the things they did have are not readily available or not good quality anymore. If you want a certain cut of meat then you should try one of the steakhouses down there. We had a great meal at YC in June.

Also I seriously doubt this had anything to do with the dining plan. It always makes me laugh that any changes or bad experiences are blamed on the dining plan.
 
I love a good filet mignon as much as the next guy. I really do. I especially love them cooked on a very hot outdoor grill until the outside is slightly charred and the inside is medium rare. Just delicious!

But, honestly, I'd like to see a few less filets on the menus and a few more interesting beef-based dishes. A guy can only eat so many filets in one vacation!

If Disney could let their chefs cut loose a little bit, and have far fewer de rigeur menu items, I'd have a much better experience. I was honestly shocked the first time we were on the DDP back in December of 2006, and every restaurant had basically the same menu. The further they get from that, the happier I'll be.

(Now, of course, if Disney's removing the filet and simply replacing it with some other de rigeur item that will be in every frickin' restaurant in the World, then no thank you!)
 
Due to the downturn in the economy here in the US, the dollar is weak and basically, the US is the international tourist destination of choice because, it's cheap! This is great that we are gather so many foreign dollars to help pump up lagging US sales, but at the same time, all of those folks, well, their diet is different than ours. While here in the US meat and potatoes had been king for many years, even the US diet is changing. So, with all of those guests with decreased demand on the supply of beef at the restaurants, it does make sense that they would decrease the offering of an expensive cut, like the tenderloin/filet, to just a few restaurants.

There is no need in supplying a bunch of restaurants with say 100 filets/night when they are only going through 20 and then wasting all of that meat and losing all of that profit. On top of that, the profit margin is probably reduced due to the increase in operating costs due to the rising price of everything. It makes sense that they are going to concentrate their efforts to keep that profit in places where it makes sense. Not to mention that from a marketing perspective a "Steakhouse" restaurant is where most people would expect to find a higher quality cut of meat, like a filet, so limiting their availablity to those sorts of establishments makes more sense.

Not everyone is on the DDP. The cost of a filet is certainly not cheap. There are lots of locals that keep Disney restaurants busy too. While they may use those AP's for a nice day/night out and go to a restaurant on property, they are not necessarily, even with the DDE, going to go for a high dollar filet. There are plenty of other more budget friendly menu options available. Again, this decreases the need for supply and shows a deminished demand for product. Add to this the need to control the "damage" of free dining's bottom line, and it's not hard to see why the filet is going to be missing for a couple of months, at the very least.

This is just my take on the situation. YMMV :thumbsup2
 
The decision does sound like a bad one from the start but it is possible that they are trying to improve the menus and not dumb them down, it will be interesting to see

My biggest question is .. what will they be replacing the filet with...

- something more original, a signature well thought and prepared entree

or

- a sandwich or pasta dish

or

- nothing

:confused3 :confused3 :confused3
 
I for one love filets and gladly pay out of pocket for them (not on the dining plan). I'd rather eat filet than all the fatty prime rib they are leaving on the menus.
 
I love a good steak. One that is cooked for me at home on my grill. I very rarely (no pun intended) get steak in a restaurant. I rarely get pasta in a restaurant. Because I can get better at home without paying a huge price for it. I want something different that I can't make at home (or I can but it's not as good).
 
My main problem is that the dishes being taken away aren't being replaced at all in most cases. The menus seem to be getting smaller and smaller and much more general across the board. All of the specialty items that make the different restaurants extra special are disappearing, IMO. In most cases, it's not anything big and most people wouldn't even notice it. At LeCellier, for example, the children's chocolate moose dessert used to come on top of chocolate chip cookies. No more cookies. LeCellier used to be the only place you could get Maple barbacue filet mignon and maple creme brulee. Because of the Canada maple syrup thing. Not anymore. Now you get a plain old filet that you can get in any other steak house and creme brulee that you can get in any other restaurant.
 
I for one love filets and gladly pay out of pocket for them (not on the dining plan). I'd rather eat filet than all the fatty prime rib they are leaving on the menus.

Exactly! :thumbsup2

DH noticed that the menus are getting smaller and smaller, that is why we do a lot of buffets (dinner) of big breakfasts and CS for dinner.
 
The Filet is still on the All Ears menu at Kona. I will be very disappointed if I can't get it...that is why I chose that restaurant. :confused:
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom