I saw it. It was not a comedy at all. More of a romantic mystery.
It wasn't very good. Johnny Depp was okay, but his acting was lacking for me. That's saying a LOT coming for me as I adore him. Angelina was plastic. She can act, but not in this.
I think I blame the director. There was one scene in particular that I would have tossed out and completely re-shot. It just didn't work for me at all and left me thinking that the director missed such a great opportunity for a terrific movie.
That, and both of the lead actors had ZERO chemistry with each other. Venice looked great, though.