My DH and I have talked about our lists
Mine are
1. Michael Vartan (Vaughn on Alias)
2. Brad Pitt (I have loved him for so long)
3. Ewan McGregor (he sings in Moulin Rouge and is Obi-Wan, who could ask for more)
4. Colin Farrell (but I want a round of penicillin first)
5. David Anders (Sark on Alias but he has to keep the British accent he has on the show)
I know my DHs list includes
1. Jessica Alba (he really really loves her)
2. Jennifer Connelly
3. Faith Hill
4. Natalie Portman
5. I can't think of his 5th right now but I am sure she probably likes to run around scantily clad.